Dad brains: How fatherhood rewires the male mind - BBC

In the months before my son was born, my partner and I attended an active birth workshop, a breastfeeding session and the hospital-run antenatal course, read a small pile of pregnancy and baby books and scrolled through loads of websites. Our notepads quickly filled up.

Among my notes of that time are details of the many ways women's bodies prepare for birth and motherhood: hormones rise and drop, organs move, brains reshape.

No one, however, told me that my brain and body were also readying for fatherhood.

My son was over a year old when I first came across that idea in Father Time, a book by primatologist Sarah Blaffer Hrdy in which she argues that men have all the necessary biological wiring to be "every bit as protective and nurturing as the most committed mother".

This piqued my curiosity. I am a resolute believer in active fathering, but I had imagined this was a cultural decision by my generation of men. Hrdy's book, however, introduced me to an entire academic field saying that our approach is rooted in biology, just dormant and waiting to be triggered.

After interviewing Hrdy and other experts and delving into the studies, I came to a simple conclusion: fatherhood changes men in ways that echo how motherhood transforms women. The more involved a father is with their baby's care, the deeper this transition becomes. These shifts in our endocrine and neural system show that the nurturing father is not a modern aberration, but a deeply rooted biological trait.

The earliest research on how fathers are physically changed by babies came from observations of other animals. These late 20th-Century studies found that many mammalian males – including other primates – show clear hormonal shifts, including rises and drops in hormones like testosterone, vasoprin and prolactin, typically associated with motherhood, as they engage in active parental care.

When the American anthropologist Lee Gettler, then an undergrad student, heard about these findings in the early 2000s, he was hooked.

"I asked [my lecturer] whether anyone was studying these questions in human fathers, and the answer at that point was largely no", says Gettler, now the director of the Hormones, Health, and Human Behavior Laboratory at the University of Notre Dame in Indiana.

The first-ever study demonstrating hormonal changes in men had just been published in 2000 by two Canadian scholars – Katherine Wynne-Edwards and Anne Storey. By the time Gettler looked into this field, it was already an established fact that fathers had lower testosterone that men without kids.

"But there's a chicken and the egg problem there, right?" Gettler explained to me. "Are low testosterone men more likely to become fathers? Or does the transition to fatherhood kind of lead to this cascade of biological changes in men?"

To answer this question and others, Gettler teamed up with the scientists running a decades-long project in Cebu City, Philippines.

In 2005, this team collected saliva samples from 624 men, with an average age of 21 years old and without partners, and tested them for testosterone, then four years later tested them again. They wanted to answer two questions: would men that become fathers in the interim have lower testosterone, and would it be even lower in fathers that spent more hours doing childcare?

When the results came back, the answer to both questions was "yes". The men that had babies showed significantly lower levels of testosterone compared to non-fathers. And the men that had spent longer looking after babies showed the largest drops in testosterone. Those that shared a bed with their infants also had lower levels.

"I think it was the first clear message in the scientific literature that men have this capacity to prepare for fatherhood," Gettler told me. In a way, he explains, this is their biology preparing them for caregiving.

Their findings are not unique. Other teams have also found that drops in testosterone during their partner's pregnancy are also linked with higher investment, commitment and satisfaction after birth, and that this hormone’s level was even linked to the men's reactions to baby cries: it made them more alert and responsive. In 2018, a team in Gettler's lab also concluded that fathers with lower levels of testosterone tend to be more involved in caring for babies and toddlers.